California Attorney General Sues Chino Valley School District Over Controversial Gender Identity Notification Policy

california attorney general Chino Valley school district gender identity notification policy

By E.Baloyo , Parent Herald Aug 29, 11:41 pm

Photo: (Photo : Justin Sullivan / Getty Images)

In a move that has garnered national attention, California Attorney General Rob Bonta has initiated legal proceedings against the Chino Valley School District. The lawsuit targets the district's recent gender identity notification policy, which mandates that parents be informed if their child wishes to be identified by a different gender or pronoun.

According to Bonta, this policy not only jeopardizes the emotional and mental health of transgender and non-conforming students but also raises questions about constitutional rights.

California Attorney General Targets Chino Valley School District's New Policy

In a groundbreaking legal action filed at the San Bernardino County Superior Court, California Attorney General Rob Bonta is challenging the Chino Valley Unified School District's Board of Education over its recently adopted gender identity notification policy, claiming it infringes on the civil rights of LGBTQ students.

Bonta, an active member of the Democratic Party, asserts that this Chino Valley school district policy poses significant dangers to the emotional, mental, and physical welfare of non-conforming students, especially in environments that are not accepting.

Andi Johnston, a spokesperson for the Chino Valley Unified School District, which is located approximately 35 miles east of Los Angeles and serves nearly 26,000 students, mentioned that they are currently working with legal consultants to evaluate the California Attorney General's lawsuit.

This is Bonta's first lawsuit of this kind, coming on the heels of similar parental notification policies being adopted in more conservative regions within his predominantly Democratic state of California.

Last month, the Chino Valley school board approved a policy requiring parents to be notified if their child wishes to be identified by a gender different from what's stated on their birth certificate or other official records.

The district, situated roughly 35 miles from Los Angeles, California, is now facing scrutiny not just for this gender identity notification policy but also for similar requirements concerning facility use and participation in sex-segregated activities.

Sonja Shaw, the Republican President of the Chino Valley School Board, has been an outspoken advocate for this controversial policy. She even made an appearance on Fox News to argue for parents' "right to be actively involved in the upbringing of their children."

Nationwide Context: The Larger Fight for LGBTQ Rights

The lawsuit filed by the California Attorney General is part of a broader wave of legislative action aimed at curtailing LGBTQ rights across the United States.

Nearly 500 state-level bills have been introduced this year to limit LGBTQ rights, with 228 of them focusing specifically on student rights, according to the American Civil Liberties Union.

Moreover, the Chino Valley School District is not the only educational institution facing legal challenges over a gender identity notification policy. Similar cases have arisen in states like Texas and New Jersey, making this a point of national concern.

Chino Valley School District President Sonja Shaw remains steadfast in opposing the lawsuit.

Shaw contends that the policy does not endanger students and instead argues that "if a child is coming to their teacher and asking to be called something other than what they were born as, they're already asking to be out in the public about it. The parent has every right to know about that."

Violation of California Constitution and Student Welfare at Stake

The suit from California's Attorney General argues that the Chino Valley School District's gender identity notification policy is in direct violation of the California state Constitution.

According to the document, this policy violates students' rights to privacy and an education free from discrimination.

Bonta elaborates in the suit that "these students are currently under threat of being outed to their parents against their will," stressing the potential harm this could cause.

Prior to filing the lawsuit, the California Attorney General had initiated a civil rights investigation into the Chino Valley School District's policy, even sending a letter in July to Superintendent Norman Enfield and the board of education.

This letter highlighted concerns about potential infringements on students' civil and privacy rights under the new gender identity notification policy.