The Planned Parenthood lawsuit against the abortion clinic ban in Utah wins!
In Utah, a judge named Andrew Stone made a ruling on Tuesday regarding a new state law that was set to ban abortion clinics.
Planned Parenthood had filed a lawsuit against the law and asked the court to prevent it from taking effect. The judge granted their request, which means that the four clinics in Utah that offer abortions can continue to operate without any restrictions.
Utah Judge Favors the Planned Parenthood Lawsuit Against the State
According to CBS, the judge in the case has agreed to postpone the implementation of the clinic ban in Utah due to preliminary evidence presented by Planned Parenthood.
Stone ruled that the legislation unjustifiably singles out abortion clinics, placing an undue burden on them. The law will be subject to further challenges in the court system, but for now, it will remain on hold.
According to Stone, the clinic ban puts a disproportionate burden on licensed abortion clinics, criminalizing their operations even though outpatient clinics provide equally safe services as hospitals.
The Salt Lake Tribune reported that Sarah Stoesz, the CEO of Planned Parenthood's Utah affiliate, said the ruling allows clinics to continue providing essential healthcare services to their patients, who have been living in chaos and confusion due to the impact of the law on their lives.
Although she welcomed the ruling, Stoesz expressed concern that the threat to the health and personal freedom of Utah residents persists as politicians continue to undermine the judicial process.
The Utah abortion clinic ban seeks to prevent new facilities from obtaining licenses, and existing licenses would be revoked by next year.
Stone's decision prevents Utah from joining other states such as Mississippi, North Dakota, and West Virginia, which have succeeded in pushing out abortion clinics.
Planned Parenthood argued that the Utah law is effectively a ban on abortion, as 95% of all procedures are performed in clinics, and hospitals are not as well equipped to provide low-cost outpatient care, including the abortion pill.
The organization also alleged that the law was enacted by Utah lawmakers and Gov. Spencer Cox to circumvent the court system while other abortion restrictions are being challenged.
Lawsuit Tries To Halt the Abortion Clinic Ban in Utah
Utah lawmakers have enacted an abortion ban on clinics as part of their ongoing efforts to restrict abortions. This law was passed less than a year after the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. The ban will lead to the delicensing of clinics, making most abortions transition to hospitals.
However, hospitals are generally not equipped to provide low-cost outpatient abortions, including administering the abortion pill.
According to the Associated Press, Planned Parenthood's attorney, Hannah Swanson, stated that hospitals in Utah only offer abortions in cases where the mother's life or health is in danger, the pregnancy is the result of a fetal anomaly, incest, or rape.
In many of these cases, patients are often referred to abortion clinics because of their lower costs.
Republican lawmakers argued that the law was designed to clarify the regulations for hospitals and eliminate sections of the legal code that would no longer be relevant once the state's abortion restrictions were fully implemented.
They also claimed that clinics could apply for expanded licenses as hospitals. The Attorney General's office in Utah chose not to provide a statement regarding the current legal proceedings.
Related Article: Rare Brain Abscesses in Kids Raises Alarm for Doctors Across the US
