In a pivotal court decision on Friday, Abby Zwerner, a Virginia teacher wounded by her six-year-old student's gunfire, was granted the ability to proceed with her $40 million lawsuit against the Newport News Public Schools system.
The lawsuit claims negligence on the part of school administrators, which Judge Matthew Hoffman of Newport News Circuit Court has allowed to move forward, citing the incident as not an inherent risk of her profession.
Negligence at the Heart of Legal Battle: School's Oversight Questioned
Zwerner's lawsuit alleges that the school administrators failed to act upon multiple warnings that the boy was carrying a gun on the day of the shooting, as well as ignored repeated red flags regarding his behavior. The legal team representing Zwerner successfully argued that the nature of the shooting was such that it could not be deemed a risk typically associated with a teacher's job duties.
The legal representatives for the school district attempted to have the lawsuit dismissed, claiming that Zwerner's recourse was solely workers' compensation, which could cover up to a decade of pay and lifetime medical benefits for injuries sustained on the job.
However, Judge Hoffman's decision refutes this claim, stating, "The danger of being shot by a student is not one that is peculiar or unique to the job of a first-grade teacher."
Zwerner, who was hospitalized for two weeks and underwent multiple surgeries for injuries to her hand and chest, has since left her position at the school. The tentative trial date is set for January 2025, while her attorneys underscored this ruling as a significant step towards achieving justice.
Despite this ruling, the school board's legal team indicated their intention to appeal, with expectations of the decision being overturned by a higher court. The school board's stance maintains that the injuries are a direct result of her occupational duties, citing the growing risks of teacher injuries by students in today's climate.
The Incident: A Tragic Day in a Virginia Classroom
The legal community had initially anticipated that the lawsuit would be dismissed under Virginia's stringent workers' compensation laws, which typically cover workplace assaults and employer negligence claims. However, Judge Hoffman's unanticipated ruling may set a precedent, challenging the norms of what is considered a work-related risk in educational settings.
In the tragic events of early January, Zwerner was shot with her student's mother's handgun, a situation that escalated quickly as she managed to protect the rest of her students before she herself collapsed. The incident sparked a renewed national debate on gun violence and sent shockwaves through the community.
The case revolves around the contention of whether the shooting incident fell within the scope of Zwerner's professional duties or if it was a personal attack. Judge Hoffman deemed the act "personal," noting the student did not threaten anyone else with the weapon.
As the case proceeds, legal experts continue to dissect the implications of Judge Hoffman's ruling on workers' compensation laws and employer liability. The outcome of this lawsuit could have far-reaching effects on the definition of workplace safety and employer responsibilities in educational environments.
Related Article: Six-Year-Old Who Shot His Teacher Allegedly Used His Mother's Gun
