Melvin Carter, mayor of St. Paul, Minnesota, has announced his intention to block the implementation of a proposed childcare subsidy program, citing misleading language in the bill.
In the upcoming November election, voters in St. Paul will decide on a proposed property tax levy that could significantly impact funding for early childhood education programs aimed at low-income households.
If passed, the levy would begin by generating $2 million in its first year, gradually increasing each year until it reaches $20 million annually by year ten. Over the course of ten years, the total revenue from the levy would amount to $110 million.
If passed, the measure would fund a "last dollar" early childhood learning program aimed at assisting low-income families.
The program would help cover costs remaining after state and federal childcare aid. The program aims to eliminate or reduce out-of-pocket childcare costs for households earning less than 185% of the federal poverty line.
Why Carter Refuses To Implement the Program
Proponents of the bill project a significant impact on the community. Initially, the program is projected to provide aid to roughly 2,500 kids. This would expand as the bill nears its final year.
However, Mayor Carter has expressed serious reservations about these projections and the overall feasibility of the program.
Speaking during a news briefing, Carter slammed the bill for using misleading language. He criticized the bill's projections.
With limited funding, Carter suggested that the city may be forced to either reduce the number of recipients or seek additional funding sources to meet the bill's promises.
He further noted that, under the proposed budget, the city would likely only be able to assist about 400 children—far fewer than the projected 2,500.
Can Carter Refuse To Implement the Program
The mayor argued that the language only grants the city authority to implement the suggestions. He further said that the city can legally refuse to impose the bill.
Council Member Rebecca Noeker, one of the sponsors of the bill, acknowledged Carter's concerns about limited eligibility. She admitted that the program is unlikely to provide financial relief to all households in the St. Paul area. However, she argued that it is worth trying to give aid to as many households as possible.
